As a car enthusiast and writer for Car News, I’ve spent years behind the wheel of countless vehicles. But there’s one question I get more than any other: “What’s the best car for a teenager?” While the answer might have once been about cool looks and powerful engines, today, it’s all about safety, affordability, and dependability.
Finding the right first car for your teen is a balancing act. You want something cool enough that they’ll actually want to drive, but also safe, reliable, and easy on the wallet. That’s why I’ve put together this list of the 10 best cheap used cars for teens in 2023.
We’re focusing on cars that offer excellent value under $10,000, prioritizing features like advanced safety tech, good fuel economy, and a reputation for reliability. Whether you’re looking for a compact city car, a spacious sedan, or even a fuel-efficient hybrid, this guide has something for everyone.
Small But Mighty: City-Smart Choices
These compact cars are perfect for navigating crowded streets and tight parking spaces, making them ideal for new drivers.
1. 2016 Smart Fortwo
2017 Smart ForTwo Cabriolet ・ Photo by Smart
Don’t let its size fool you, the Smart Fortwo is big on safety and fuel efficiency. The 2016 redesign brought more shoulder room, a smoother ride, and even electronic crosswind correction for added peace of mind. Its small size makes it a breeze to park, and the fuel economy is unbeatable for city driving.
Expert Insight: “The Smart Fortwo is a great option for teens who primarily drive in urban areas. Its compact size makes it incredibly maneuverable, and its fuel efficiency is tough to beat.” – Emily Carter, Automotive Journalist
2. 2017 Hyundai Accent
Photo by Hyundai
The Hyundai Accent offers a more traditional small car experience. Available as a sedan or hatchback, the 2017 model boasts excellent fuel economy and a surprisingly spacious interior for its class. Plus, you might even find one with some factory warranty remaining!
Parent Tip: Look for a 2018 model if you can stretch your budget a bit. It comes standard with a backup camera, a valuable safety feature for any new driver.
3. 2015 Honda Fit
Photo by Hyundai
The Honda Fit is a small car with big personality and even bigger practicality. Its versatile interior can handle anything from weekend adventures to moving day, while its fuel-efficient engine keeps running costs low. The 2015 model introduced improved safety features, including a standard backup camera, making it a smart choice for young drivers.
Why We Love It: The Fit’s “Magic Seats” fold flat or flip up, creating a surprising amount of cargo space for a car its size.
4. 2016 Kia Soul
Photo by Kia
The Kia Soul stands out with its funky styling and spacious interior. Its boxy shape provides ample headroom and cargo space, while its elevated driving position gives a commanding view of the road. The 2014-2019 generation is known for its refined interior and impressive build quality, making it a great long-term option.
Safety First: The Soul comes standard with essential safety features, and higher trim levels offer advanced safety tech like blind spot monitoring and rear cross-traffic alert.
Room to Grow: Spacious Sedans and Hatchbacks
These larger vehicles provide more passenger and cargo space without sacrificing affordability or fuel efficiency.
5. 2018 Nissan Sentra
Photo by Kia
The 2018 Nissan Sentra offers excellent value for money in the compact sedan segment. It’s spacious, fuel-efficient, and comes standard with important safety features like automatic emergency braking and a rearview camera.
Top Tip: While a 2015 or newer model is ideal for its improved crash test ratings, you can often find even more affordable options from earlier years.
6. 2015 Mazda3
The Mazda3 proves that affordable cars can be fun to drive. Available as a sedan or hatchback, the Mazda3 delivers sharp handling, a stylish interior, and a fuel-efficient engine. Look for a 2015 model for features like optional automatic emergency braking and lane departure warning.
Driver’s Choice: The Mazda3’s responsive handling and sporty driving dynamics make it a more engaging option for teens who enjoy the art of driving.
7. 2012 Toyota Prius
Photo by Toyota
For eco-conscious teens, the Toyota Prius is an excellent choice. This iconic hybrid delivers exceptional fuel efficiency without sacrificing practicality or reliability. While a 2012 model might be the newest available under $10,000, the Prius’s legendary dependability makes it a smart buy even with a few miles on the odometer.
Green Machine: The Prius teaches eco-friendly driving habits without the range anxiety associated with all-electric vehicles.
Extra Space, Extra Peace of Mind
Need more room? These mid-size cars and wagons offer the space and safety features growing families need.
8. 2015 Hyundai Sonata
Photo by Hyundai
The 2015 Hyundai Sonata is a well-rounded mid-size sedan that offers a comfortable ride, plenty of interior space, and impressive fuel economy. Its sleek styling and upscale interior make it feel anything but cheap.
Family-Friendly: The Sonata’s roomy backseat and spacious trunk make it a practical choice for teens with younger siblings or those who frequently carpool with friends.
9. 2013 Subaru Outback
Photo by Subaru
The Subaru Outback is a versatile choice that blends the spaciousness of an SUV with the car-like handling of a wagon. Its standard all-wheel drive provides added confidence in challenging weather conditions, while its roomy interior comfortably accommodates passengers and cargo.
Adventure Ready: The Outback is ideal for teens who love the outdoors or live in areas with snowy or icy winters.
10. 2014 Chevrolet Impala
The Chevrolet Impala might be a full-size sedan, but it drives with surprising agility. The 2014 redesign brought improved handling, a more refined interior, and a choice of fuel-efficient engines.
Safety Matters: Opt for a model with the optional V6 engine for improved acceleration and easier merging on the highway.
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Car for Your Teen Driver
Finding the perfect first car for your teen is about more than just ticking boxes on a checklist. It’s about finding a vehicle that balances their needs and your peace of mind. Be sure to prioritize safety features, reliability, and affordability, and don’t forget to involve your teen in the process – after all, they’re the ones who will be behind the wheel.
What do you think of our list? Have a suggestion for a great cheap used car for teens? Share your thoughts in the comments below!